The medical community traditionally has
relied on potent drugs to relieve severe
pain. But in a number of academic settings
across the country, health-care practitioners
are adding another therapeutic weapon
to the mix -- they're helping patients
harness the healing power of their own
imaginations.
The use of guided imagery, or mental
images, to evoke physical benefits is
perhaps the oldest form of therapy known
to man, explained David E. Bresler, a
founder of the Academy for Guided Imagery
in Malibu, Calif. In fact, imagery is
woven into the fabric of many ancient
cultures' healing rituals, he said.
Today, academic researchers are studying
guided imagery's use as an adjunct to
more traditional medical treatments.
"I think it's just the beginning,
really, even though it's been around a
long time," said Bresler, whose academy
instructs clinicians, including pediatricians,
in the use of imagery to evoke physiologic
changes that promote healing. A traditionally
trained Ph.D. neuroscientist, he first
became intrigued with alternative methods
of pain relief in the early 1970s as founder
and director of the University of California,
Los Angeles, Pain Control Unit.
While much of the ongoing research is
preliminary, practitioners of guided imagery
are encouraged by initial results among
children and adults.
Nola Schmidt, associate professor of
nursing at Valparaiso University in Valparaiso,
Ind., recently completed a pilot study
at Children's Memorial Hospital in Chicago
examining guided imagery's effect among
children with pain due to sickle cell
disease or stem cell transplants. Of the
17 participants, eight were randomly assigned
to listen to guided-imagery tapes created
especially for each child.
Most tapes were vague, allowing the children
to insert different scenes each time they
listened to a recording. "For example,"
Schmidt said, "a tape may start out:
'OK, we want you to relax and close your
eyes, take a deep breath, feel the air
go in, feel the air go out.' " The
child is invited to imagine being in "one
of your favorite places" and to describe
the sights, sounds and smells he or she
encounters.
Children in the experimental and control
groups also kept pain diaries. Their entries
recorded when and where they felt pain,
what they did to feel better and how much
they hurt before and after those interventions.
On a 0-to-10 scale, children in the guided-imagery
group had an average post-pain intervention
score of 4.3, a point lower than children
in the control group. While the difference
was not statistically significant, Schmidt
believes it is "clinically"
significant.
"If it works for you, and it reduced
your pain by one point or two points,
isn't it worth it?" she asked.
Bresler noted that his academy trains
a lot of pediatricians to use guided-imagery
techniques. But kids aren't the only patients
benefiting from this mind-body therapy.
Sports psychologists use it to enhance
athletes' physical performance. And cancer
centers often use it to relieve patients'
pain and nausea.
Carol L. Baird, an associate professor
of nursing at Purdue University in West
Lafayette, Ind., recently tested guided
imagery with a relaxation component among
older women suffering from osteoarthritis.
Half of the 28 volunteers in the pilot
study listened to recordings that described
a pleasant scene and guided listeners
to engage all of their senses. After 12
weeks, the experimental group experienced
a significant reduction in pain compared
with women in the control group. The guided-imagery
group also had increased mobility, the
study showed.
What's more, a separate study involving
the same volunteers found that guided
imagery with relaxation seemed to improve
their quality of life, she said.
Baird thinks the guided-imagery approach
has exciting potential. "For one
thing, it's so easy to use," she
noted. It's also inexpensive and easy
to teach, making it suitable for patients
to use in their own self-care, she added.
Of course, it may not be for everyone,
especially people who have difficulty
visualizing images in their heads, Baird
acknowledged. In the future, she plans
to do studies that measure people's "imaging
ability."
On the other hand, guided-imagery experts
say the technique has minimal side effects,
if any. So why not try it?
Schmidt suspects science someday will
reveal a concrete biological reason why
guided imagery works. In fact, animal
studies suggest that images in the brain
can stimulate neurotransmitters that,
in turn, block pain receptors, she said.
But for patients garnering relief today,
a neurochemical explanation may not be
necessary.
"I mean, who cares why it
works, if it works," she said.