Eating large amounts of
red meat may double young women's breast
cancer risk, a study suggests.
US researchers writing
in Archives of Internal Medicine looked
at over 90,000 pre-menopausal women.
Having one-and-a-half
servings of red meat per day almost doubled
the risk of hormone receptor-positive
breast cancer compared to three or fewer
per week.
UK cancer experts said
animals in the UK were not given growth
hormones which are used for US animals.
Researchers from Brigham
and Women's Hospital and Harvard Medical
School in Boston studied women who were
part of the Nurses' Health Study II from
1989 to 2003.
The women filled out
questionnaires in 1991, 1995 and 1999,
on which they recorded how often they
regularly consumed more than 130 different
foods and beverages.
A portion of meat was
defined as beef, pork or lamb as a main
dish, in a sandwich or eating a hamburger,
bacon, hot-dogs or other processed meat
as part of a meal.
Every two years, they
reported whether or not they had developed
breast cancer. Cases were confirmed through
hospital records and pathology reports.
The researchers also
looked at the whether the women's tumours
were fuelled by the hormones oestrogen
or progesterone.
By the end of the study,
1,021 women had developed breast cancer.
There were 512 cases
of cancers which were oestrogen and progesterone-receptor
positive, 167 that were negative, 110
with mixed status and 232 with unknown
status.
Public health implications
When the researchers
looked at meat intake and cancer risk,
it was found that women who ate more than
one-and-a-half servings of red meat per
day had almost double the risk of hormone
receptor-positive breast cancer compared
with those who ate three or fewer servings
per week.
Writing in Archives of
Internal Medicine, the researchers led
by Dr Eunyoung Cho, said: "Several biological
mechanisms may explain the positive association
between red meat intake and hormone receptor-positive
breast cancer risk.
They say cooked and processed
red meats have been shown to contain cancer-causing
chemicals such as heterocyclic amines
which are created during the cooking of
red meat.
A second potential link
is the growth hormones which are given
to cattle in the US, although not in Europe.
The researchers also
say red meat is a source of heme iron,
which previous research has shown fuels
the growth of oestrogen-induced tumours.
Dr Cho's team added:
"Given that most of the risk factors for
breast cancer are not easily modifiable,
these findings have potential public health
implications in preventing breast cancer
and should be evaluated further."
'Complex causes'
Dr Sarah Rawlings, of
the Breakthrough Breast Cancer charity,
said: "Very little is known about diet
and breast cancer risk because we eat
a variety of foods and separating out
the effect of an individual food is difficult."
She added: "Previous
studies looking at red meat and breast
cancer have been inconclusive.
"This study relied on
women accurately recalling their diet
over the past year and was carried out
in the US where animals receive growth
hormones not permitted in the EU.
And Maria Leadbeater,
nurse specialist at Breast Cancer Care,
added: "To date we are still a long way
off fully determining the many and complex
root causes of this disease and it is
an area for further research.
"Further studies will
need to be done to fully establish the
exact nature of any link between a diet
high in red meat and breast cancer.
"The benefits of eating
a healthy and varied diet are well established
and the biggest risk factors for breast
cancer remain gender and increasing age."