"This is paving new ground, scary new
ground," said Dr. Ronald D. Chervin,
the director of the University of Michigan
Sleep Disorders Center, who was not associated
with the study. "The fact that children
with sleep apnea would score worse on neurocognitive
testing than normal children is not new. The
new part is actually showing evidence of neurochemical
changes in the brain."
For the research, published in the Aug. 22
online issue of the journal Public Library
of Science Medicine, Dr. Ann Halbower,
medical director of the pediatric sleep disorders
program at the Hopkins' Children's Center
in Baltimore, and colleagues looked at 31
children between the ages of 6 and 16. Nineteen
of them had untreated severe sleep apnea,
a condition associated with repeated nighttime
awakenings and daytime grogginess.
Using a special type of magnetic resonance
imaging (MRI), the researchers found that
those children with sleep apnea had significant
changes in two brain regions associated with
higher mental function: the hippocampus and
the right frontal cortex. They also determined
that the children had altered ratios of three
brain chemicals -- N-aceytl aspartate, creatine
and choline -- which are indicative of brain
damage.
The kids with sleep apnea had lower mean
IQ test scores than the healthy children (85
compared to 101) and performed significantly
worse on standardized tests that measure executive
functions such as verbal working memory and
verbal fluency.
"Executive function is the ability to
take an old memory and put it to use in a
new situation," Halbower explained. "It's
what makes smart people smart. The clinical
implications are that doctors need to understand
that sleep apnea is more of a problem that
we thought it was. It's not just a disease
of old people."
Because untreated sleep apnea appears to
impair brain chemistry, its effects could
be permanent, Halbower added.
"We can only assume that it could turn
an otherwise smart kid into a mediocre kid,
which could mark him for life," she said.
But it's also possible that these effects
are reversible. Halbower's next study will
try to determine whether sleep-apnea treatment
can restore normal brain chemistry and cognitive
function.
The standard treatment for sleep apnea in
children is surgical removal of enlarged tonsils
and adenoids, which can obstruct breathing.
Other treatments include removal of excess
tissue in the back of the throat or nose and
the use of continuous positive airway pressure
(CPAP) machines to maintain normal airflow
during sleep.
Because untreated sleep apnea may have even
more severe effects in children than in adults,
the sooner it's detected, the better, Halbower
said.
So parents should be aware that one of the
most important symptoms of sleep apnea is
frequent pauses in breathing that result in
arousal from sleep and stirrings in bed. Other
symptoms include snoring, labored or loud
breathing, coughing, choking, gasping, excessive
nighttime sweating and, sometimes, bedwetting
by children older than 6.
"If you're looking at an infant or young
child, they may sleep in odd positions,"
Chervin said. "They may sleep with their
rear end up in the air and their head tilted
back, which is probably an effort to open
their airway."
Daytime signs of sleep apnea include sleepiness,
an inability to concentrate and poor performance
in school. "But it should be remembered
that younger children with sleep apnea aren't
just sleepy," Halbower pointed out. "They
also show signs of hyperactivity and irritability."
Studies have also shown that some children
with sleep apnea also have attention deficit
hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
"If you have a child who snores and
has behavioral problems during the day associated
with ADHD, conduct disorder or oppositional-defiant
disorder, talk to your pediatrician about
the possibility that there could be a relationship,"
Chervin said. " I don't think that sleep
apnea explains a majority of ADHD, but it
may explain a minority of ADHD."
While the prevalence of snoring in children
is about 16 percent to 20 percent, the prevalence
of true obstructive sleep apnea in children
is only 2 percent to 3 percent, Halbower said.
But, like the adult version, children's sleep
apnea is usually unrecognized, and it's often
difficult for doctors to diagnose because
its effects may not be evident during a typical
examination.
However, Chervin cautioned that the Hopkins
study, because of the small number of children
studies, shouldn't be considered the last
word on any possible link between sleep apnea
and brain damage.
"I would describe it as preliminary
news, because it opens up a whole area that
needs further investigation," he said.
"It'll be fascinating to see if the neurochemical
changes that were present before treatment
are still present after treatment."