To believers, homeopathy is a natural approach
to medicine, a holistic therapy that takes the
entire patient into account. Homeopaths believe
that "like cures like" -- in other
words, when diluted to microscopically tiny
levels in water, small quantities of substances
that in bigger doses would cause symptoms
can now cure them.
But debate over homeopathy's effectiveness --
or lack thereof -- rages, with kinder critics
calling homeopathy nothing but a placebo effect
and harsher ones labeling it just plain fake.
Few dispute that sales of homeopathic products
are rising. Sales of homeopathic remedies are
up 20 or 30 percent over the past year, said
Peter Gold, a spokesperson for the National
Center for Homeopathy (NCH) in Alexandria, Va.
Solid statistics are hard to come by, but way
back in 1995 U.S. retail sales of homeopathic
products had already reached $230 million, according
to data from Marketresearch.com.
Homeopathic medicines are drug products made
by specialty homeopathic pharmacies, as described
in the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia of the United
States. The practice dates back 200 years to
an 18th-century doctor from Germany, Dr. Samuel
Hahnemann, who first described homeopathy.
According to advocates, the practice centers
on an attempt to stimulate the body to recover
itself, taking a very close look at the nature
of symptoms and the "whole person."
For instance, if someone has a cough, a homeopathic
practitioner will note whether the person with
the cough gets worse when he breathes cold air
or if it sounds like a deep bark. Those two
different symptoms might require very different
homeopathic substances to treat them, practitioners
say.
Homeopathic medicines are made from plants
such as dandelion, minerals such as sodium chloride,
animal products such as snake venom or even
more familiar medicines, such as penicillin.
"Homeopathy addresses each person in his
or her totality, as opposed to treating physical
symptoms alone," said Sue Gelber, a homeopathic
practitioner in Davis, Calif. She said each
remedy is first "proven": the method
by which a homeopath discovers the primary and
secondary actions of each remedy.
First, she said, the remedy is administered
to healthy people until symptoms appear. Then
the subjective and objective symptoms of each
of these "provers" are detailed and
recorded. Then, a homeopathic practitioner "listens"
to symptoms and matches them to those recorded
in the library of provings.
Janet Shultz, a homeopathic practitioner in
El Segundo, Calif., offered up one example.
She said that for a person with seasonal allergies,
she picks from 15 or 16 remedies, based on symptom
information provided to her by the person. "There
are over 3,000 remedies and over 12 popular
potencies, so that is 36,000 possibilities.
This is where it takes extreme knowledge and
expertise in questioning," Shultz said.
Well-known skeptics were contacted by HealthDay
for their views on homeopathy, but declined
to participate in the article. Their reasoning?
Most said that any article that includes the
viewpoint of homeopathy advocates is giving
the practice more legitimacy than it deserves.
Homeopathy's image did take a well-publicized
hit last August with the publication of a major
study in the prestigious medical journal The
Lancet. That study found that, despite the
fervent beliefs of practitioners, homeopathy's
effect on patients is probably mostly placebo.
In their study, researchers from the University
of Bern, Switzerland, and elsewhere compared
110 placebo-controlled, randomized trials of
homeopathic remedies against 110 conventional
medicine trials. They also matched them for
disorder and type of patient outcome. The trials
included studies of treatments for respiratory
infection, surgery and anesthesiology.
The authors concluded that there was "weak
evidence" for a specific effect of homeopathic
remedies, but very strong evidence for effects
of conventional treatment.
To no one's surprise, the article triggered
outrage in the homeopathic community. Many homeopaths
claimed the study had fundamental flaws in its
design.
In any case, individuals who decide to try
out homeopathy should seek out an experienced
practitioner, according to the NCH's Gold.
While stressing that the NCH is "not a
licensing body," he noted that the center's
Web site does include a directory of practitioners.
And he added that many homeopathic providers
come from a wide variety of backgrounds -- some
may be chiropractors by trade, others pharmacists,
dentists or acupuncturists. That's why it's
important to find out specifically what their
training is in homeopathy, Gold said.